James H wrote:daveG wrote:
They know full well the radio 3-ites will never let them do that (radio 3 is the only BBC FM station that isn't subjected to horrible that horrible compression applied when they make CDs, its still true true HIFI)
I did not know that! I thought all fm transmissions were compressed like that!
I belive via reading various publications (which of couse could be full o shit) that they are all compressed to a certian extent, all were compressed to the minimum dicatated by the contraints of FM transmission, however in the last 10 years they appear to have applied much more to the popular music stations, possibly for good reason, maybe the mastering of popular music creates huge inconsistency between tracks, maybe its to conserve server space? but they apply less to radio 3 where the listenership will notice. If you tune in to liseten to Sibelius symphony no. 2 recorded by the London philharmonic in 1967 you are going to know how it should sound, how loud those strings are in comparison to the flute, how deep that tympany sits into the sound stage,compress it and the soundstage is flat, loud passges are not as loud, quiet passges are pulled up in the mix, all attack and decay present in the the live or psuedo live performance is gone.
they know full well you won't notice it with heavily produced modern music because the aim is not to sound LIVE so when its ingested into the playout servers they just compress everything to limit the peaks so less knob twiddling is necessary track to track, programme to programme. Its not how the band and producer intended but it works on a low to medium quality play back system OK. trouble is the FM broadcast version is poorer than the CD version which by its nature is poorer than an analogue master (if it existed) due to the contraints of the standard applied to CDs (which was defined in 197?)
CDs are already compressed to make them sound "immediate" to catch your attention. most listen to music as background to their life, you can't be stoppting to apprecite that delicate near silent passage....it needs boosting over the sound of the traffic
The Time is now Moloko CD has litlle compression..the bass is killer yet sounds normal.
modern life is rubbish by blur don't know what they did, heavy thumping mush, which i love, i love that album but the original vinyl could be practically a different album, delicate tunes with masses going on which is just drowned on the CD version..
yet the BBC apply similar compression techniques to their own broadcast make FM sound bad? why? so people buy DAB?
where have we seen that before? anyone buy a music centre/MIDI system in the 1980s, strange how crap your records sounded played on that cheap plastic turntable, worce than your old pioneer or garrard, worse than even Compact Cassette (phillips) and how good CD sounded in comparison (phillips/sony), who made it? and who had a vested interest in making CD a success? who owned the record companies and vinyl pressing plants?
right enough misery and daft conspiracy theory.... who fancies a sticky bun and a nice cup of tea?
Dave