- Wed Nov 21, 2012 3:54 pm
#486522
Everyone pays a different rate of tax. If people at the bottom pay less why shouldn't people at the top pay more?

chrysostom wrote: I think my opinion of this was forged from seeing my dad work 2 jobs (a day and a night) and overall getting taxed around 45%, even though he worked incredibly hard in a deserving field (no farmer jokes please).Not even if you earn over 200'000 a year would you get taxed overall at 45%!
chrysostom wrote:Toph, I think that being forced to pay a higher proportion of your income to benefit society than everyone else just because people think you can do without the money is immoral. Make the 40% tax voluntary and I think you'll see the true morality of society as a whole (there would always be good people like Batman's parents who want to do the right thing).I think we shall have to agree to disagree. I understand where you're coming from, it's just my view is slightly (quite a bit) to the left of yours! Your dad wouldn't have been taxed 45% on the full amount though (I know you know this - just pointing it out for others).
I think my opinion of this was forged from seeing my dad work 2 jobs (a day and a night) and overall getting taxed around 45%, even though he worked incredibly hard in a deserving field (no farmer jokes please).
chrysostom wrote:An interesting one about fraud. My friend who is a teaching assistant was paid over the summer months, as were her colleagues - but her contract meant she wasn't due to be paid during that time (which she didn't know), but her colleagues were. She was made to pay all the excess back and (whilst being very annoyed) understood she had to. But had to work out a payment plan.Whereas my mum - who also works for a school (sorry, 'academy') has relatively recently discovered that since she started, she hasn't been paid for the full day - every day they have missed off a (albeit small) portion of the day over a couple of years - it adds up. She asked the school to repay it, they refused. She is not pursuing it because she doesn't want to upset the apple cart and is worried about how much hell they could potentially make her life if she did pursue it.
Deadly wrote:Topher wrote:Stuff about Thatcher....You are a disgrace and I'm looking forward to when someone you respect dies so I can rub your liberal face in it.
ess wrote:Not even if you earn over 200'000 a year would you get taxed overall at 45%!You're right, it would be 43.8% with one job (inc. national insurance contributions) - but the second job wouldn't include the untaxable allowance - so would probably bump it up a tiny bit . Unfortunately I didn't do my dad's accounts so just had to go on anecdotal things I heard. Working it out now, based on how much I think he earned and the tax codes associated with having 2 jobs, as well as excess NIC contributions - he would have only kept 61.5% of his overall salary, while he worked 16 hour days, whereas I keep 80.1% of my salary while working 9 hour days.
Topher wrote:She asked the school to repay it, they refused. She is not pursuing it because she doesn't want to upset the apple cart and is worried about how much hell they could potentially make her life if she did pursue it.That's really outrageous that they refused - especially considering that she's a permanent employee and her employers know she's been short changed.
Deadly wrote:On a different note I'm annoyed that Chris isn't making a statement on the issue. It's not going to go away until he provides some information directly.Maybe he's been advised by his lawyer not to? I think you're right though - I think he should make some kind of statement. Back when Jimmy Carr was going through this (is he still going through it?) I had thought Chris might make SOME mention of it. Maybe this is why he never did.
Badger Mark wrote:When Jimmy's tax avoidance came to light he confronted it and apologised. He did his tv show as normal and got the piss taken out of him for 45 minutes about it. It's hardly ever mentioned now.Deadly wrote:On a different note I'm annoyed that Chris isn't making a statement on the issue. It's not going to go away until he provides some information directly.Maybe he's been advised by his lawyer not to? I think you're right though - I think he should make some kind of statement. Back when Jimmy Carr was going through this (is he still going through it?) I had thought Chris might make SOME mention of it. Maybe this is why he never did.
Deadly wrote:When Jimmy's tax avoidance came to light he confronted it and apologised. He did his tv show as normal and got the piss taken out of him for 45 minutes about it. It's hardly ever mentioned now.It's called "getting in front of the problem" in the PR world, and it's the only way to do things nowadays IMO.
Charlalottie on Twitter wrote:Just remembered that I played pool with a satanist last night. Really should go out on a Friday more often.
Charlalottie wrote:Had a good night last night. We lost the pub quiz but had my hair plaited by a viking.
chrysostom wrote:An interesting one about fraud. My friend who is a teaching assistant was paid over the summer months, as were her colleagues - but her contract meant she wasn't due to be paid during that time (which she didn't know), but her colleagues were. She was made to pay all the excess back and (whilst being very annoyed) understood she had to. But had to work out a payment plan.Are you sure that's right? Because normally when you work in a school, you still do get paid during the summer months. If you're only entitled to 40 weeks a year they'll normally average it out over 12 months. I've never known a school not do it like this.
boboff wrote:But your lack of intelligence and short attention span shouldn't really effect the grown up debate we are having so * off, ya prick.
IMO I understand
neilt0 wrote:I'm glad I started this thread. It's definitely not going round in circles.