- Sun May 25, 2008 12:49 pm
#343486
So you think a half truth is better than making a child feel better?


foot-loose wrote:Granted, it would make sense to spare the gory details, but kids should be able to deal with death and the general nastiness of the world.In my experience kids sometimes deal better with humans passing away, than they do their own rabbit! Let the innocence continue for a bit longer, it's kind of sweet.
S4B wrote:So you think a half truth is better than making a child feel better?How is it a half truth? The fox killed the rabbit. That is the full truth. If you add in "it ripped open its stomach and fed slowly on its intestines while it was still alive then decapitated it" then you are merely adding extra information to the original story.
ladbroke wrote:In my experience kids sometimes deal better with humans passing away, than they do their own rabbit! Let the innocence continue for a bit longer, it's kind of sweet.Well, I have no experience so I am probably not qualified to discuss such things. I'm sure it's easy for me to sit and say "ahh just tell them" but it's a different case when you actually have to do it!

S4B wrote:There is a right time to start telling them the cruel truth about the world and you do it in stages.It is natures way really, foxs kill for fun, and the thrill of it. Still not going to tell him that though!
In my experience kids keep asking questions which is a good thing, however not so much when they start asking what the fox did to the rabbit, where the rabbit is now and why the fox did it. As he fox didn't eat the rabbit you can hardly tell them it was "Nature's Way" and everything has its place in the circle of life can you!

foot-loose wrote:I'm totally with footy on this one. It's absolutely crucial that kids understand things like this right from the start. I wouldn't get too gory, but I would absolutely explain that the fox killed the rabbit - I would probably even try to explain why. A 6 year old should absolutely have an understanding of such things. My cat regularly brings home dead birds and rodents which my 4 year old sees, when he asks me about it I tell him. I know it would be more difficult with a pet, but I would still be honest. I don't believe in being sentimental about such things.S4B wrote:So you think a half truth is better than making a child feel better?How is it a half truth? The fox killed the rabbit. That is the full truth. If you add in "it ripped open its stomach and fed slowly on its intestines while it was still alive then decapitated it" then you are merely adding extra information to the original story.
And how is lying to the child a good call? They grow up thinking the world is pink and fluffy and that is a load of bollocks. There is a metaphorical fox round every metaphorical corner ready to rip your metaphorical head off. The sooner we get that, the quicker we start taking our metaphorical anti-fox spray out with us!
Charlalottie on Twitter wrote:Just remembered that I played pool with a satanist last night. Really should go out on a Friday more often.
Charlalottie wrote:Had a good night last night. We lost the pub quiz but had my hair plaited by a viking.
Yudster wrote:About me: See, she doesn't say a lot, but when she does, it's very accurate.
boboff wrote: Anyway, it's your child, and none of us are perfect parents, so it's your call chap. Not nice when that happens though.Yes. None of what I said alters the fact that when you are faced with it in your own family, you deal with it how you best can.
Charlalottie on Twitter wrote:Just remembered that I played pool with a satanist last night. Really should go out on a Friday more often.
Charlalottie wrote:Had a good night last night. We lost the pub quiz but had my hair plaited by a viking.
foot-loose wrote:I'll wave my high definition willy any chance I get!
Yudster wrote:No, someone was ranting about militant lesbians and it made me think of her!
Deadly wrote:Topher wrote:Stuff about Thatcher....You are a disgrace and I'm looking forward to when someone you respect dies so I can rub your liberal face in it.
rustybike wrote:I can't go for a drive as I've given myself a set allowance on petrol for work (* commuting to shitty Crawley).I know someone who commutes from Brighton to Crawley too.... maybe you could lift share? Or maybe you are him.
I'm only 29 by the way.Ballbag wrote:That is a seriously good suggestion, you should look into that bustyrike. And good luck, stick at it - it'll all be worth it in the end.rustybike wrote:I can't go for a drive as I've given myself a set allowance on petrol for work (* commuting to shitty Crawley).I know someone who commutes from Brighton to Crawley too.... maybe you could lift share?
Charlalottie on Twitter wrote:Just remembered that I played pool with a satanist last night. Really should go out on a Friday more often.
Charlalottie wrote:Had a good night last night. We lost the pub quiz but had my hair plaited by a viking.
Topher wrote:The getting your own place thing is difficult for me as well... aren't you only 21? I'm 24 now and I need to be out (not least because my mum's none too keen on the idea of having me back.)Indeed. My mum kinda took me back half heartedly anyways as she thought me and my sister would be constantly arguing, but suprisingly it's going ok between me and her which is making my mum happy - I just get various moments of wanting to strangle her because of her constant stupidity (and that's putting it lightly).
Ballbag wrote: I know someone who commutes from Brighton to Crawley too.... maybe you could lift share? Or maybe you are him.I might have been if I was a "him".
foot-loose wrote:I'll wave my high definition willy any chance I get!
Yudster wrote:No, someone was ranting about militant lesbians and it made me think of her!
boboff wrote:I assume by the use of phrase "Mrs" she might be from a Todger Dodger.A what?!
foot-loose wrote:I'll wave my high definition willy any chance I get!
Yudster wrote:No, someone was ranting about militant lesbians and it made me think of her!
foot-loose wrote: you really can be quite gay sometimes Toph
foot-loose wrote:I'll wave my high definition willy any chance I get!
Yudster wrote:No, someone was ranting about militant lesbians and it made me think of her!