Were talkin daytime here, Judge Jules is the best "dance" DJ:
Radio 1 in 2001
1. Mark Radcliffe & Marc (Lard) "Riley Minouge"
I admit they did talk a lot, but you had to listen to what it was about. But their features like Missing Words an Lards Classic Cuts did it for me, and I do remember them saying somthin funny about the Olsen twins and me laughing my head off about it, but I can't think of what that was!
2. Chris Moyles
He has always been top, and although he has always been arrogant & said he is the best DJ of the time (some would agree), he had some good words for Mark & Lard and said he had learned a lot from them in the BBC north powerhouse documentary on the last Mark & Lard show. Some of his features I sometimes dislike (not too keen on carpark catchphrase), but I think his best moments involved Jon Culshaw & those phonecalls!
3. Scott Mills
Although at first I found him annoying, he has developed as a DJ. And I have taken more time to listen to him since Mark & Lard have left. His best moments have to be the celeb calls (especially with the Roy Walker one

). Also I think he did a good job on the "Sunday Surgery" after September 11th (the Sunday after the Tuesday it happened), so he got a lot of credit for that.
Radio 1 2005
1. Mark & Lard left

so in place it is... Chris Moyles!
2. Scott Mills
3. Spoony
I just couldn't think of anyone better to replace Mills in the 3rd place.
I think Moyles was better at 3pm after Mark & Lard (perfect schedule), because of his features and the competition he got from MnL. But now there is no-one who can match (although Mills can sometimes) Moyles on Radio 1, he has no-one to compete with. Still rather him in the mornings than Sara Cox though *shudders*, lovely (!) This weekend she was talking about people farting & burping at the same time... just while you are sitting down for afternoon lunch!