[Nicola_Red]

Here's the link to the 2018 one:

https://www.makesomenoise.com/product/t ... cast-2018/

Still getting a 404 from those old ones, will keep checking.

[unzippy]

Chris said he has no intention of re releasing the old Pubcasts. The intention has always been to release them for a limited time only.

[neilt0]

Chris has said they are not going to re-release the old ones.

[Nicola_Red]

I know he said that, but the 2017 link worked up until about two weeks ago, so I don't think what was said on air about it being "limited time" was the whole truth. Anyway, they're apparently gone now.

Edited to add: if you have any strong feelings as to why we should/shouldn't add them to the archive, feel free to voice them here and we'll make a decision.

[Harry Briggs]

Now they’re not available to buy online I reckon we should add them. I’ve bought the previous 2 and it’s not a complete archive on here without them.

[James H]

I can see the reasoning behind it being a complete archive.

Just interesting to see what Global will make of it, I'm sure Chris himself probably isn't fussed if they're mirrored here, especially if you can't get them any more.

[neilt0]

Chris doesn't want them up. He's said that several times.

[Topher]

I don't think it's right to do it. It undermines the attempt at charity fundraising if folks know they can wait a couple of years to get it free here (not saying they would do that, but I don't think it's right to give the opportunity).

[Randomisation20]

Any suggestions I’m struggling technically to download the pub cast actually onto my PC managed to get into Apple Music but I wanna try and keep a copy of it any suggestions how I can download an MP3 ? Didn’t have a problem last year as I just right clicked and saved

[Evs]

No reason they can't be added to the archive long into the future. Maybe when he leaves Radio X is the right time. As long as somebody (most of us I imagine?!) has a copy they're not exactly lost forever are they.

[Smoggy78]

In my opinion, now that the new Pubcast is available and the old ones aren't I don't see why you can't put the old ones on. I can't buy them and we can't contribute to charity anymore so no harm is done. I think just as long as the money has bee raised then its harmless.

[Elok]

Would there be an issue with putting a current make some noise donate link with the downloads.
Obviously only be voluntary but still...

[daydotz]

Maybe put a link to make some noise donation page with a note saying these were paid for if you have enjoyed them consider making a donation

[Matthague]

Hi,
Can you not have a moyles.net just giving page, where a mod sends a weblink to the pubcasts when a donation is made?

[swaddon1903]

It is being taken down on Friday at some point, Chris confirmed this morning.

[kenyan_dave]

I'm way behind as I'm in July with the show at the moment, and the link seems to have gone, would anybody be willing to share the podcast if i donate and provide proof?

[jeddeth]

I am also way behind and need to find a copy. I would be happy to make a donation to Make Some Noise or any other charity you prefer.

[edgeshat]

hi everyone,,,
Has the pubcast been taken down,,, never got a chance to download as work away from home a lot and no good wifi.
Had a look on the web site but can't find ? Tia